What is leadership fit recruitment?

Kristina Thomas • May 15, 2024

Have you ever watched a sports team where the coach just seems... out of sync with the team? It's not that they're not skilled or knowledgeable. It's just that something isn't clicking. That is what we call "Leadership fit". Hiring and retaining top leadership talent remains a challenge for many organisations. 


So, what is this Leadership Fit, and why is it the secret sauce for retaining top leadership talent?


Understanding Leadership Fit

It refers to the compatibility between the leaders and the organisations they work for. It's the harmonious symphony that happens when a leader's values, career goals, and behaviours are in tune with the organisation's culture, objectives, and ethos as well as with the team they engage with. When this alignment is off, even the brightest leaders can flicker and fade. But when it's on point, it's like magic. The leader thrives, their teams are engaged, and the organisation soars.


A classic example is Sarah, a CFO who moved from a manufacturing firm to a fast-paced start-up. Despite her impeccable credentials, Sarah felt out of place due to a mismatch in organisational culture and personal values. While Sarah had the right skillset and transferrable competencies, the environment and its culture didn't align with her expectations of with her team, colleagues and leadership as well as her way of operating.

This lack of alignment is not based on skillset but rather on organisational values, structure and culture. Sarah had accomplished wonders in a large environement where there was strong process and structure as well as people decidated to support with all the different aspect of a business. She had great vision and leadership in that context.

Moving forward to her new appointment as the CFO in a start-up, while  she struggled to adapt to an environment that didn't have the resources and  processes to operate at the level she used to.

Such cases highlight the importance of Leadership Fit beyond just professional qualifications.



A recent survey conducted by the Organisational Behavior Institute found that businesses with a high Person-Organisation Fit among their leaders experienced a 45% increase in retention compared to those that didn't prioritise it.



Practical Steps for Organisations to address Leadership-Fit


  1. Organisation and leadership assessment: Identify the organisation unique attributes and challenges as well as the type of leadership that thrives in that environment.
  2. Role assessment: Crafting a position description that highlight the skills required as well as the challenges it will face. 
  3. Recruitment campaign: Designing a campaign that target the right leaders and balance your communication between the benefits of the role as well as its challenges
  4. Holistic onboarding:  Designing an onboarding experience that immerses new leaders in the company culture and connects them with cultural ambassadors.
  5. Executive Coaching: Supporting your new leaders in navigating their new environment through executive coaching. Programs such as LeaderShift executive coaching have been designed specifically to support new leaders during their transition period, a period that is a highly stressful and uncertain period for new leaders.
  6. Feedback loop: Encouraging open dialogue about values and objectives ensures alignment. Regular workshops and training sessions can also help reinforce the organisation's values.
  7. Exit Interviews: Conduct exit interviews to understand the factors contributing to leaders' satisfaction and dissatisfaction.
  8. Flexibility and Well-Being: Offer flexible work arrangements and well-being initiatives that reflect the organisation's commitment to work-life integration.


The Bottom Line

Hiring and retaining leadership talent is not just about competitive salaries and fancy titles. It's about the less tangible, but incredibly powerful, sense of fit between the leaders and the organisation. When leaders feel like they're in the right place, they're not just employees—they're advocates, innovators, and the kind of leaders who create legacies.


If you need further support, feel free to contact KTalent to learn how we use organisational psychology best practices to address leadership fit. Visit https://www.ktalent.com.au/ to learn more.

Related blogs

By Kristina Thomas August 28, 2025
The False Promise of “Hiring Alone” In the high-stakes world of leadership recruitment, securing the right executive is a monumental achievement. Yet, despite exhaustive search processes and rigorous selection criteria, studies consistently reveal that nearly 40% of new CEOs fail to meet expectations within their first 18 months. The gap between appointment and impact is where many leadership failures silently take root. The traditional mindset sees hiring as the culmination of the leadership journey. It’s the trophy moment, the announcement, the celebration. But this is dangerously incomplete. Appointment is merely the entry ticket; the true challenge lies in transitioning that leader from “candidate” to “trusted, effective change-agent” within a new complex, dynamic organisation. Success in leadership is as much about who you hire as how you land. The Designed Landing: A Strategic Imperative This concept of a designed landing reframes executive onboarding as a deliberate, psychologically informed process. It acknowledges that leaders confront not only new responsibilities but new cultures, relationships, and expectations that require careful navigation. The first six months in a new role are among the most demanding for any senior leader. They must navigate a new culture, align stakeholders, build credibility, and deliver early results, all while under close scrutiny. Even the strongest leaders tell us this period can make or break their long-term success. Introducing LEAP: KTalent’s Holistic Answer to Leadership Transitions At KTalent, we have translated these insights into the Leadership & Executive Adjustment Program (LEAP), a proprietary onboarding framework co-designed with organisational psychologists and leadership experts. LEAP is not an off-the-shelf orientation. It is a bespoke, science-backed program that integrates: Immersive onboarding plans tailored to leader roles and stakeholder ecosystems. High-touch, iterative coaching focused on accelerating impact, enhancing communication, and navigating organisational complexity. Real-time progress monitoring and ongoing support to pre-empt challenges and sustain momentum. This approach has demonstrated transformative results: enhanced satisfaction for both the organisation and the new leader, increased speed-to-impact, and organisational alignment that elevates business performance. Takeaway: Rebalance Your Leadership Equation The future of executive success demands a paradigm shift from “Hire and Hope” to “Hire and Design.” Organisations that embrace designed landings will realise that true leadership impact comes not from the rarity of talent alone, but from the quality of transition. The LEAP program addresses that gap; it is the bridge that turns leadership skills into organisational reality. For those committed to making leadership appointments serve as powerful catalysts for growth and resilience, designed landings are a new solution to reduce derailment and increase success among your leadership team. Appoint thoughtfully, land intentionally, and lead decisively. That is the leadership equation for the future.
By Kristina Thomas July 28, 2025
The Leadership Failure No One Talks About Leadership failure rarely starts with performance. It starts before that, in the gap between appointment and alignment. And no one’s paying enough attention to it. Executive onboarding is one of the most overlooked drivers of leadership success or failure. It’s often treated as a handover, a checklist, or a few courtesy meetings. In reality, it’s a high-risk period where pressure is high, context is low, and impact is expected fast. This Isn’t an HR Task, it’s a Leadership Priority Many organisations still see onboarding as an operational process. IT access. Welcome emails. A 90-day plan. But for senior leaders, especially external hires, onboarding is not about orientation. It’s about establishing influence. This is when new executives start: Building trust and credibility Navigating organisational politics Decoding the culture beneath the surface Shaping perceptions that will follow them for years And the window is narrow. Miss it, and even the strongest leaders may never fully recover. Why Good Leaders Struggle? The reality is: Expectations are high but rarely explicit Stakeholders are watching but not always supportive Leaders are expected to drive change before they’ve built trust Women or diverse leaders face even more scrutiny Without the right onboarding strategy, even the best hires operate in a vacuum, disconnected, misaligned, and vulnerable to early reputational damage. A Smarter Approach to Executive Transitions  This is where leading organisations are shifting their focus. They’re not just appointing leaders, they’re enabling them. At KTalent, we work with Boards, CEOs, and Heads of People to support onboarding as a strategic leadership transition, not a checklist. Our role is to help organisations reduce risk and accelerate performance by designing the right conditions for a new leader to land well and lead early. Our LEAP (Leadership & Executive Adjustment Program) is embedded in organisational psychology and includes: Contextual onboarding plans tailored to the business landscape Stakeholder alignment to clarify expectations and priorities Coaching that supports trust-building, influence, and momentum Tools to help new leaders navigate culture, decision-making, and internal dynamics Leadership onboarding insights This isn’t onboarding-as-usual. It’s leadership enablement. Because leadership doesn’t start at appointment. It starts with alignment.
By Kristina Thomas July 22, 2025
Traditional Leadership Transitions Are Failing, But Some Organisations Are Changing the Game. Here’s How
Executive Transition Coaching
By Kristina Thomas May 5, 2025
Leadership today is less about capability and more about context. This post explores why modern leadership transitions are high-stakes—and how we can better support new executives from day one. #ModernLeadership #ExecutiveTransitions #OrganisationalPsychology #HRLeadership
More Posts